This post comes directly from a conversation I had last night with
Matt Tettleton. Mat is very opinionated on baseball and often times very wrong
1. But here is my list of the best all time pitchers.
10. Warren Spahn - We often forget about this guy but he is probably the most dominate southpaw ever
2.
9. Cy Young - It's hard to compare because it was a different time, but he was the best at that time.
8. Nolan Ryan - "Hitting of Nolan is like trying to drink coffee with a fork." -- Reggie Jackson.
7. Sandy Koufax - Would be ranked much higher if he'd player past the age of 30.
6. Grover Cleveland Alexander - Tied for third in wins (373) and second in shutouts (90).
5. Bob Gibson - He was the best of his era.
4. Roger Clemens - I'm going to go ahead and put an asterisk next to this one.
3. Satchel Paige - We can only imagine what he would have done if he'd been born white. Paige was once accused of cheating he said, "I ain't never thrown an illegal pitch, it just every now and then I throw something they ain't never seen before."
2. Walter Johnson - Ty Cobb once said the only time he's ever been scared in his life was the first time he saw a Walter Johnson Fastball
3.
1. Christy Mathewson - 17 seasons with 373 wins, 2.13 ERA and .665 win pct. I'll admit this is a little of a surprise for number one, but the numbers don't lie. However, Mathewson's strikeout numbers are also fairly low because he wasn't a power pitcher at all. I see this as another example of his greatness, the fact that he couldn't relying on over powering his opponents but rather he had to be more creative to succeed. He also succeeded despite having a girls name
4.
1) Except for is opinion that Nolan Ryan was effectively wild.
2) But maybe Randy Johnson deserves an honorable mention here.
3) Ty Cobb was once stabbed in a mugging.
4) Like a
Boy Named Sue.